starring: ASHLEY MICHELLE GRANT & JACKSON TILLER
Humiliated in front of the school, klutzy bookworm Celeste reinvents herself to steal heartthrob Jace from his mean girl ex and breaks his heart. But Jace isn’t what she expected, and the longer she fakes it, the more she stands to lose.
REVIEW
Some learning points here. I always want to help champion things for people.
So when Alta asked if I wanted to be a collab on the FFAS2 posts, (all I did was press a button, I never ever take money for these things) I was confident I was on safe ground as FFAS is so good
Now I think I need to be a lot more cautious
Because the final issue I talk about here was a big error of judgement in my view. I gave an outline of the scene to my husband....he winced and said that's a bit close to home
And so unnecessary as someone should have flagged it and said let's just rewrite it to be this
I'm not saying verticals have to be the moral standard
But when something that as a brand is so associated with being a comfort watch, something safe and beloved, this mis-step jars more
And does everyone who worked so hard of the production a disservice.
It's such a shame
And sadly will make me a lot more cautious , I am going to have to ask a lot more questions before I agree to help champion things.
Things I Liked:
👏 The Performances
Austin Cooper is easily my fave role of Jackson Tiller, he seems more at ease in it, and has some great moments when vying with Jin, including a deadly side eye.
Ashley Michelle Grant is always great, and once again grounds the story as Rachel and provides the emotional connection.
Molly Anderson brings it as Amanda, and has some hysterical moments - her waking up gasp, the ‘puleeeeeese’.
I’ve always had a thing for Laze, so thank you for finally casting him as a lead - he is utterly brilliant as Jin
I thought Elin Bautista as Cici was one of the best things about FFAS, and she just picks up where she left off. Totally natural. Her offer to not wear headphones in the house to keep Austin and Rachel together is heartbreaking.
🎉 More Positives
Everything about the character Jin, from the moment he calls Rachel Noona I am gone (I came from K-Dramas), the connection with Cici, the dance routine at the end. Always thought verticals should take more inspo from K-Dramas, and this is perfect, even the fact that Jin ends up being the second male lead who doesn’t get the girl (and who I secretly prefer). Classic K-Drama trope.
Giving Cici more to do with the introduction of Sam, and her relationship with the three adults.
To make a sequel work the writers had to find a reason to break up Austin and Rachel. I was dreading it being because of jealousy or arguing, much better that it was because of the double marriage, and Rachel trying to protect Austin. It’s tenuous but it worked.
And this shows how incredibly low the bar is at the moment but I appreciated the lack of rage bait bullying, violence, sexual violence and hurling of abuse.
Always sure one of the appeals of Falling For A Superstar is that it was a kinder, gentler vertical.
The Not So Good:
✍🏻 The Plot / Writing
This is where we struggle.
One of my fave things about FFAS were the ensemble quality of the characters, and I missed Damian and Leslie who were my faves.
Jin is great, Clint is an egomaniac, but none of the other new characters are given anything to work with or make them stand out. I missed the ensemble feel.
❓What did they do to Rachel?
The appeal of Rachel is that she is the girl next door, doesn’t care about celebrities and doesn’t take any of that nonsense. This is lost in this one. Feels like she is trapped and weighed down by the job.
I can just about buy that she would give Amanda a second chance, but she would find a way to fight back against the blackmail threat, not just go along with it.
And making her the star of the film at the end? WHAT?!?
🚗 Austin the Uber Driver
I have never liked the plot point where one character thinks the other is dead, spills their heart to someone who turns out to be the presumed dead ex lover. Plus it made no sense why he would be the driver when she grabs as Uber immediately after we see him driven off in the ambulance.
I can forgive lapses in vertical logic, but the problem is I ended thinking Austin is a jerk for doing this to Rachel. Slightly salvaged by the fact she tells him as much.
✍🏻 The Writing of Amanda
I also didn’t like the way Rachel and Austin spend the last third playing Amanda. When they are almost trash talking her in the trailer, and she overhears… when I end up feeling sorry for Amanda and not liking the main characters something has gone wrong.
Amanda was always one of my fave villains because it wasn’t really about the man. She wanted the fame. The first half is great - my favourite scene is when she confronts Austin for not playing along, and cannot comprehend why he wouldn’t want press and fame.
Unfortunately the writing of this character quickly deteriorates as soon as she says “If I can’t have him no one can”.
It’s such a shame wasting someone with Molly Anderson’s talents. She isn’t even given a good final line as she is dragged away by the police. (Personally I think what we need is Amanda’s redemption story, I’m thinking Sharpay’s Big Adventure here.)
And The Biggest Misstep…
I had dawning horror from episode 55 onwards when I realised that they were including a plot point about bullets and blanks being switched on a film set, and the gun causing a ‘death’.
I can’t believe this was included.
Given there have been two high profile deaths on film sets because of gun errors this felt like a massive error of judgement.
And totally unnecessary - just make it something else, an electric shock, switch knives, trip over a cable.
I don’t understand how this will have gone through multiple people, and no one said maybe this isn’t the best idea, let’s change it to this.
It jars much more in FFAS2 because this is a feel good vertical, designed to be more of a sweet rom com, comfort watch. This error totally pulled me out of the story, and made it uncomfortable to watch.
I feel I am being tough here - FFAS is such a super vertical, and this means the sequel is being held to a higher standard than if it was a standalone vertical.
This may feel unfair to some.
It’s not that you can’t make a sequel when the original storyline is complete - see My Secret Agent Husband 2 which is utterly brilliant. It was always going to be hard to make something as good as the original, partly because the story was complete.
For the first half, I had FFAS2 rated as a really good try, with some great ideas, fun moments, and it was going to be a 4 star review. Then the plot starts flailing and we have the whole mess of the last 8-10 episodes.
I have no idea how to rate it now. So I have ended up with this: it’s complicated.
✍🏼 DETAILS
2025
Available on Alta